Luke Gromen's July 10, 2026 Tree Rings, read against Sean's live book. Triggered by MacroSignal Issue #7's claim that Gromen flipped bullish on US equities. Short version: he did — but only in nominal terms, and the rest of the issue is a loud re-underwrite of the debasement core you're already positioned for.
MacroSignal moved its equity lean from −0.42 (bearish) → −0.10 (mixed), not to outright bull, and captioned it "Luke Gromen flipped bullish on nominal terms." That checks out against the primary source. Gromen's actual base case: US (and Japanese/Korean/German) stocks "keep grinding higher in local-currency terms (but not in gold terms)… until a brief bond-market crisis, during which stocks fall sharply," then "skyrocket to new all-time highs in local currencies, but falling sharply in gold terms."
So four asterisks before you read this as "Luke turned bullish on the S&P": (1) it's a nominal debasement melt-up — he still expects equities to lose to gold; (2) it isn't a fresh flip — he frames it as the secular trend "since 2022 (really since 2000)," just re-emphasized while fading the "debasement-trade-is-over" consensus; (3) a sharp sell-off comes first in his base case; (4) his book is unchanged — "significantly overweight gold, gold miners, cash/T-Bills, and US electrical-infrastructure equities" — gold and picks, not the broad index.
Net for you: No trade is forced. The issue confirms the deployed book — gold ladder into the Warsh dip, BTC patience, bond-short — more than it changes anything. The one live tension is your SPY/IWM Mar-2027 puts vs. a grind-higher nominal tape (see Action 3).
Gromen builds the whole issue on Adam Tooze's coinage: the dollar is "no longer a reserve currency — it has become a vehicle for unfettered capital accumulation." His mechanism: levered hedge funds (via the UST basis trade, booked as "nonprofits"/Cayman shells) have been the marginal buyer of Treasuries since foreign central banks stopped growing holdings in 2014. That flips the old reflex — higher equity vol now drives 10y yields up, not down, because a stock drop forces hedge funds to de-gross the basis trade.
The five "rules of the road" he draws from it are the spine of everything else:
The "Profit Dollar" means the US can never again "crash stocks to save USTs" — because crashing stocks now crashes USTs too. Any risk-off, the Fed/Treasury must supply liquidity to keep stocks up and the UST bid intact. The only viable playbook is to devalue USD & USTs vs. gold — so the secular trend of stocks up in dollars, down in gold continues. "We remain significantly overweight gold, gold miners, cash/T-Bills, and US electrical-infrastructure equities."
This is the line MacroSignal picked up. In his own words:
Our base case is that Japanese, Korean, German, and US stocks will all keep grinding higher in local-currency terms (but not in gold terms)… until there is a brief bond-market crisis, during which time stocks will fall sharply, and force these nations to explicitly choose "save the bond market"… after which these markets should skyrocket off the lows to new all-time highs in local currencies, but falling sharply in gold terms (and probably BTC terms).
And, watching German equities rise even as Chinese competition guts German industry, he goes further:
…it makes us question whether western stock indices will ever fall substantially again in local-currency terms for more than a brief, untradeable moment, and that the only way they will fall will be relative to gold.
Translation: this is not a fundamentals-up call — it's the debasement escalator. Nominal up, real (gold-denominated) down. It's genuinely more constructive on nominal index levels than the flat-out bearish framing of prior issues, which is why MacroSignal's delta reads as a flip. But it's the same secular thesis, and his money stays in gold/miners/cash, not the index.
The most actionable section for you. Consensus (per the Bloomberg piece he quotes) is that the debasement trade died when Trump nominated Kevin Warsh to the Fed on Jan 30 — gold fell 13% that day (steepest in 4 decades), BTC collapsed, DXY bottomed, market now prices two rate hikes by Q1 2027. Gromen calls that "almost certainly wrong":
Warsh has exactly two choices — blow up the US fiscal/debt position and economy, or not. If you think he'll blow it up, the debasement trade is over. If (like us) you think there's a zero percent chance of that, then the debasement trade is NOT over — it is merely resting until it makes Warsh its boy, just like it made Powell and Yellen and Bernanke its boy.
His fiscal math: the US needs a much weaker USD + higher inflation (negative real rates) to keep receipts above the "Big 3" (entitlements + defense + gross interest) and avoid a debt spiral. A hawkish Warsh sends USD up → receipts down → yields up globally → foreigners dump USTs to defend currencies → spiral → forced liquidity injection anyway. "The only thing that matters is the level of the USD."
For your book: this is a direct re-underwrite of the gold/BTC core and of your gold ladder — the Warsh-driven washout IS the dip your monitor targets (T1 ≤$4,050 / T2 ≤$4,000, DXY-independent since the Jul 6 re-band). Gromen is effectively telling you the consensus selling the debasement trade is handing you the entry.
Gromen: not holding physical bullion at a double-digit % of liquid net worth (10–15%) "is quickly becoming irresponsible." Near-unanimous across the panel (MacroSignal 19/20 bull). China's reserves rose most since 2023 even as bullion tumbled — official-sector buying the dip. Straight through-line to your 7 BTC + PHYS core and the ladder.
On MSTR's $8.3B loss / BTC sale: Gromen wants to buy back the BTC he sold Nov 2025, but is staying patient — "when there's blood in the water, the sharks don't demur," and Strategy may have to sell more. He sees "a better (lower) re-entry point." Mirrors your BTC GTC ladder exactly (T2 $55–58K / T3 $48–53K). Don't chase.
Note the honest puzzle he flags: Japanese capital fleeing bonds into the Nikkei has not bid BTC — over the last year the Nikkei is up more in BTC terms than in yen. He reads it as near-term caution for BTC until Japan is forced to explicit YCC.
Germany (DAX) and Japan (Nikkei) both show stocks up AND 10y yields up since Trump's election — the classic "emerging market with a fiscal crisis" signature. Germany is boosting 2027 borrowing on weak (China-driven) tax revenues; foreigners are dumping JGBs at the fastest pace in three years. His frame: these creditor nations are running the Reagan/Fourth-Turning "borrow-and-spend-on-defense" playbook, forcing the eventual "save the currency or save the bond market" choice — and they'll choose save the bond market → crush the currency → let stocks rip.
For your book: reinforces the bond-short pillar (your remaining HYG Sep 78P ×20, and the structural rationale behind the SPY/IWM long-dated puts as crisis hedges). Western sovereign yields biased up until a break forces liquidity — consistent with how you're hedged.
China blacklisted MP Materials & USA Rare Earth. Gromen: the US can't rebuild a REE ecosystem in 3–5 years — it'll require aggressive subsidies that undermine the bond market → YCC → inflationary. Bullish gold, upward pressure on western yields. Not a position you hold; flags a potential future theme.
Gromen is wary of tech's "La-La Land valuations" and the AI job-loss leverage ("5% of white-collar work is enough to break the system"). Chinese models now >30% of OpenRouter token traffic as the cost gap widens. Mild tension with your GOOG/TSLA sleeve — though you already trimmed AMD/TSM (Jun 29). MacroSignal #7 flags AI-capex bear 14/18.
Bessent / Hamiltonian economics: Treasury Sec. Bessent used an Economic Club of NY speech + same-day WSJ op-ed to declare a return to Hamiltonian economic statecraft — tariffs + subsidies to reshore strategic industry (semis, AI, critical minerals, shipbuilding, pharma), reciprocity, "national capacity." Gromen reads this as structural, inflationary, and ultimately YCC-forcing — i.e., more fuel for the debasement/hard-asset core. Deliberate policy signal, not noise.
| Thesis pillar (Jul 10) | Read | Your position | Action |
|---|---|---|---|
| Debasement NOT over (Warsh fade) | Confirm | Gold ladder (T1 ≤$4,050 / T2 ≤$4,000), 7 BTC core, PHYS powder | Hold the plan; the Warsh dip is the buy |
| Gold 10–15% of NW "or irresponsible" | Confirm | 7 BTC (~8% NW) + bullion + miners | On-thesis; nothing to do |
| BTC — patient, lower re-entry | Confirm | GTC ladder $55–58K / $48–53K | Don't chase; ladder stands |
| Bond-short (yields up till break) | Confirm | HYG Sep 78P ×20; long-dated index puts | Keep HYG line; Sep 1 check |
| US equities up in nominal terms | Nuance | GOOG/TSLA/SPCX sleeve; SPY/IWM Mar-27 puts | Sleeve on-side; see puts (Action 3) |
| Electrical-infra equities OW | Confirm | Exited VST/CEG/GEV (May); not held now | Watchlist re-look if reshoring accelerates |
| AI/tech valuation risk | Tension | GOOG/TSLA (trimmed AMD/TSM Jun 29) | Live with it; conviction sleeve, sized |
| Rare-earth reshoring → YCC | Watch | Not held | Note as future gold-tailwind theme |